Governor-elect David Crowley of Wisconsin hasn't even been sworn in yet, and he's already talking about handing his state's electoral votes to whichever candidate wins the national popular vote. Governor Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania — a state Donald Trump carried twice — has signaled the same interest. Between them, that's 29 electoral votes potentially pledged to a scheme that would let New York and California pick every president from now until the sun burns out.
The scheme has a name. It's called the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, and after the 2026 blue wave, it's closer to activation than it's ever been.
Here's how it works. States pass legislation committing their Electoral College votes not to the candidate their own residents chose, but to whoever wins the national popular vote. The compact doesn't take effect until states representing 270 electoral votes — the number needed to win the presidency — sign on. Right now, 18 states plus the District of Columbia have already joined. With newly Democratic trifectas in Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, the math to hit 270 is suddenly very real.
The constitutional architecture they're trying to sidestep isn't obscure. Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 gives state legislatures authority over how electors are appointed. Compact advocates lean on that provision to argue they don't need a constitutional amendment — they can just legislate the Electoral College into irrelevance state by state. What they don't advertise as loudly is Article I, Section 10, Clause 3, which requires interstate compacts to receive Congressional consent. Attorney General Todd Blanche doesn't sound worried about the legal fight. "It shouldn't get past the district court," Blanche said. "I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this."
That optimism should be tempered by the speed at which the other side is moving.
Governor Mikie Sherrill of New Jersey — whose state already joined the compact — framed the pitch the way every compact advocate does. "Our votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is," Sherrill said. "That's not democracy." It's a clever line. It's also the same argument that would have dissolved the United States Senate in 1787. The Founders built the Electoral College precisely because pure majority rule in a continental republic hands permanent power to population centers and leaves everyone else without meaningful representation. New Jersey's governor isn't describing a flaw in the system. She's describing the system working as designed — and she doesn't like the results.
The compact's backers point to 2016, when Trump won the Electoral College while losing the popular vote, and 2000, when George W. Bush did the same against Al Gore. Those are the cases that animate the movement. What they leave out is that popular-vote-Electoral-College splits have happened exactly five times in American history — 1824, 1876, 1888, 2000, and 2016. The compact would restructure presidential elections permanently to solve a problem that has occurred in roughly seven percent of all elections. And it would do it without the two-thirds congressional supermajority and three-fourths state ratification the Constitution requires for amendments.
That's not reform. That's a workaround by people who looked at the amendment process, realized they couldn't win it, and decided to go around it.
Inez Feltscher Stepman of the Independent Women's Forum, writing in National Review, issued a warning that deserves more attention than it's getting. "It seems like the right has barely realized the importance of the fight that's about to begin," Stepman wrote. She's not wrong. The legal challenge via Miller v. Washington was dismissed in 2019 for lack of standing — before the compact had enough votes to matter. The Supreme Court's Chiafalo v. Washington ruling upheld states' authority to bind electors, which compact advocates now cite as wind at their backs.
The 2024 election — in which Trump won both the popular vote and the Electoral College — didn't slow the movement down for a single news cycle. That tells you everything about what this is actually about. If the concern were really "every vote should count equally," a popular-vote winner taking the White House through the Electoral College would have been cause for celebration. Instead, the push accelerated the moment Democrats picked up state legislatures.
Five newly blue states. 270 votes within reach. No constitutional amendment required — if the courts let it stand.
